Greatest Hits Survivor Game

[ethelu]

That would be a close call for me too, ethelu - but I'm actually voting for See You Again (the sheer disappointment of it being released in the otherwise musically more innovative BA era was the decider for me, I'm afraid)

Agree with you on SYA. I like it, but don't love it.

[carriefan14]

All-American Girl

[CarrieUDomination]

ROUND TWO is over. With results of 4-2-1-1, UNDO IT is OUT. Remaining contenders for ROUND THREE are:
1. Something in the Water
2. Little Toy Guns
4. Jesus, Take the Wheel
5. Don't Forget to Remember Me
6. Before He Cheats
7. Wasted
8. So Small
9. All-American Girl
10. Last Name
11. Just a Dream
12. I Told You So [w/Randy Travis]
13. Cowboy Casanova
14. Temporary Home
16. Mama's Song
17. Remind Me [w/Brad Paisley]
18. Good Girl
19. Blown Away
20. Two Black Cadillacs
21. See You Again

Farawayhills and ethelu, we have stuff in common! lol. AAG and SYA are two of my least favorite Carrie singles, along with MS. However, if I were a voter, this round I'd probably vote for AAG cause that is honestly probably my least favorite Carrie song in general. Ironically, it's also the song that got me really interested in Carrie waaaaay back in 2008 lol.

Vote for which song you want out next! Round three ends at some point on Sunday.

[tgbrinker]

Mama's song

[Claire2004]

Mama's Song

[Carrieroxmysox2011]

Remind Me.

[maddkat]

Just a Dream

[Smokyiiis]

Mamas Song

[jptexas]

Love SYA, this is like getting rid of the kids you've known for 10 years, some of them. I'll say Remind Me since it wasn't really Carrie's song.

[countrymama22]

Mama's Song

[ethelu]

All American Girl

[CarrieUDomination]

ROUND THREE is over. With results of 4-2-1-1, MAMA'S SONG is out. Remaining contenders for round four are:
1. Something in the Water
2. Little Toy Guns
4. Jesus, Take the Wheel
5. Don't Forget to Remember Me
6. Before He Cheats
7. Wasted
8. So Small
9. All-American Girl
10. Last Name
11. Just a Dream
12. I Told You So [w/Randy Travis]
13. Cowboy Casanova
14. Temporary Home
17. Remind Me [w/Brad Paisley]
18. Good Girl
19. Blown Away
20. Two Black Cadillacs
21. See You Again

Vote for the song you want out next! Round four ends at some point on Tuesday.

[MSCarriefan]

REMIND ME (since it really was Brad's)

[JB172]

This is starting to get tough.

I will go with Last Name

[Smokyiiis]

Don't Forget To Remember Me. ^^and I agree: this is tough now

[AdamLikesCarrie]

Don't Forget To Remember Me

[Zman312]

Cowboy Casanova.... Cant stand that song!

[sam_vzla]

Last Name

[tgbrinker]

Easy - Don't Forget to Remember Me

[cmuf2011]

Cowboy Casanova