i wish this wasnt posted here. not because i can't take a negative review, but its pretty obvious these guys just plain don't like her. one of their editors even called her a karaoke singer in the comments.
i wont be that surprised if they were this harsh on carrie because they know they'll get a storm of negative reactions, and hits on their site.
It's just the typical garbage that 9513 puts out about Carrie.
The 9513 has discovered the way to stay in the spotlight and be noticed is to rail against Carrie Underwood!! Nobody even knows or cares that they exist till they come out with a hatchet job reveiw!! They get hits from irate Carriefans and they get hits from all the haters that just reinforses there veiws! Carrie Underwood is way beyond this kind of fabricated reveiw! So if i was you guys i would consider the sourse and remember they were utterly wrong about everything they have ever said about her. So instead of admitting there wrong they come up with more confuluded points that have no basis in reality! I think there just pissed because obviosly they have absolutly no influance whatsoever because Carrie is country music and they are living in the past and cant face the present or future!!! Posted via Mobile Device
I just signed on now, and look at the nasty comments that Jim Malec had to say about Carrie. He is a known Carrie critic on the 9513, but tonight he was particularly harsh. I am not sure what started all the trouble, but he is a self-righteous little jerk who seems to thrive on his own perceived self-importance. This blog comment says it all. It is unreal!
DIRECT QUOTE from a 9513 Blogger:
Jim Malec
January 30, 2009 at 4:42 pm Permalink Oh. My. God. Are we really going to start dissing Taylor Swift here? Again? Is there room for only one young female pop country songstress?
OK, let’s open that can of worms.
Taylor Swift may be a crappy singer, but at least I feel like she has something to say. She has a story she’s trying to tell. Underwood? Not so much. And, in Swift’s case, that counts for something.
Underwood’s supposed greatness is predicated on her voice, but if she’s going to build a career on a foundation of singing, she deserves to be held to a very high standard when it comes to…well…singing.
And frankly, it all feels underwhelming to me. When she sings, I feel like I’m listening to a really, really good karaoke singer. All the notes are there, but there’s this detachment, almost as if she doesn’t own her own material when she sings it. Underwood has a fantastic voice, but she is nowhere near a top-tier singer, because she doesn’t seem to understand that singing is about more than hitting notes.
Agreed. Before I would ignore those who would say they just had something against Carrie, I though people just couldn't take criticism but honestly it's obvious they have some problem with Carrie and anything and everything she does or sings.
yes some of the people on that site are just rabid haters disguised as impartial journalists. lol
Tonight they really showed their true colors in their comments. They attacked not only Carrie, but her fans too, calling her fans Fanbots or something like that.
What did they expect the reaction to be from Carrie's fans? Joy? They trashed her yet again, unfairly, so it is pretty clear they are not an impartial blog.
lets leave these guys alone. they aint changing. why waste our time on them? most of the reviews have been good; dont let them ruin things for us. posting comments on their site just increases hits for them
May you always have
enough happiness to keep you sweet;
enough trials to keep you strong;
enough success to keep you eager;
enough faith to give you courage;
and enough determination to make each day a good day!"
The 9513 has discovered the way to stay in the spotlight and be noticed is to rail against Carrie Underwood!! Nobody even knows or cares that they exist till they come out with a hatchet job reveiw!! They get hits from irate Carriefans and they get hits from all the haters that just reinforses there veiws! Carrie Underwood is way beyond this kind of fabricated reveiw! So if i was you guys i would consider the sourse and remember they were utterly wrong about everything they have ever said about her. So instead of admitting there wrong they come up with more confuluded points that have no basis in reality! I think there just pissed because obviosly they have absolutly no influance whatsoever because Carrie is country music and they are living in the past and cant face the present or future!!! Posted via Mobile Device
lets leave these guys alone. they aint changing. why waste our time on them? most of the reviews have been good; dont let them ruin things for us. posting comments on their site just increases hits for them
true... and that rick person just attacked me too, personally. lol It is the same old crusty group of haters going back and forth. You can't really have a conversation with them because if you disagree with them, you are attacked.
guys for real!
i am not big fan of Carrie like most of you and i can give my unbiased opinion, Carrie's version is gorgeous... those folks at 9513 have an agenda against a few girls, i don't think we should hear them, they try to use "WISE" words to make people believed them, to me they are losers...what is important is the listeners to like the song.
Carrie is Country Queen of Music Today! Carrie is here to stay. They should be prasing Carrie for sticking to country music instead of crossing over. Carrie is the real deal and people can;t seem to leave Carrie alone! ITYS is a great song! Carrie did a incredible job on her rendition of the song!
^ But oddly, they seem to love Taylor Swift, despite the pop remixing and lack of country on her album. So it is sort of hypocritical, that they like a pop re-mixer, but hate Carrie for not being "country" enough. lol They are definetly inconsistent and hypocritical.
So that tells me they are not just blinded biased traditionalists: They just hate Carrie. Period.
I say Carrie just put out the music you like and screw the bias critics w/ an agenda (unbias critics welcomed though ) . I'm so sick of 9513 and their biases. They don't feel anything from Carrie's music b/c they choose to not feel anything from the get go. Carrie we love you and your music and you are doing a great job and you and your music does touch people. If people like this don't like it, tough. I bought your album SH b/c of your song JTTW which moved me so much I cried as i heard it on the radio not even knowing it was you singing this song until the dj mentioned your name after the song was over. I said "wow, Carrie Underwood?....really? that girl from AI?, really? she sounds like a pro. and this song is so touching/moving." That song had an effect on me so much that I then checked you out on youtube and loved your live performances and so bought your album and starting following you ever since and loved her music. You bring alot of joy, happiness, and brightness into this world. Keep it up
Screw the bias critics!!!
I say Carrie just put out the music you like and screw/f*** the critics. I'm so sick of 9513 and their biases. Carrie we love you and her music and you are doing a great job If people don't like it, tough.
lol true! What we learned from this is that the haters will keep hating on Carrie even if she released an entire album of Hank Williams' type songs, and dressed in a gingham polka dot dress with a straw hat. lol
So she may as well release that G n R cover album after all! lol
Some of you are just taking it too seriously. You shouldn't have expected anything any better. They called CR the worst album of 2007 and gave a thumbs down to every single released thus far (except JAD, but who knows what it would have gotten if it wasn't over the certain subject matter).
You know i dont think its Carrie they hate i think its what Carrie represents they cant stand!! The fact that she was discovered on a reality show is something that there never gonna get over! And they tolerate Taylor simply for that reason and shes not Carrie! I agree with Jade on this one screw them who cares what they say they have proven that there biases trump any rational thought!! As They show Carrie no respect i say show them the same by not giving them what there after thats hits on there site!! Carrie is the real deal and they cant stand it so its really pretty pathetic and funny at the same time!!! Posted via Mobile Device
Actually this whole thread is making me laugh! Granted that not every review and every person on this planet is going to appreciate and recognize the incredible talent of Carrie. I'm okay with that. I'm also over the top proud of the following:
Teen Choice Awards Choice Reality Star - female
Billboard Music Awards Top-Selling Hot 100 Song of the Year: "Inside Your Heaven"
Top-Selling Country Single: "Inside Your Heaven"
Country Single Sales Artist of the Year
Gospel Music Association Awards Country Recorded Song of the Year: "Jesus, Take the Wheel"
CMT Music Awards Female Video Of The Year: "Jesus, Take the Wheel"
Breakthrough Video of the Year: "Jesus, Take the Wheel"
Academy of Country Music Awards Top New Female Vocalist of the Year
Single Record of the Year: "Jesus, Take the Wheel"
NARP organization of record retail merchants Breakthrough Country Artist
Music Row Critics Pick
Country Music Association Awards Female Vocalist of the Year
Horizon Award
12th Annual Inspirational Country Music Awards Mainstream Country Artist of the Year
American Music Awards Favorite New Breakthrough Artist
Billboard Music Awards Female Country Artist of the Year
Album of the Year
Country Album of the Year
Country New Artist of the Year
Female Billboard 200 Album Artist of the Year
Canadian Country Music Awards SOCAN Song of the Year: "Jesus, Take the Wheel"
Worf Music Awards Female Act of the year
New Act of the year
Album of the year for "Some Hearts"
Best Female Country Video of the year for "Jesus, Take the Wheel"
33rd People's Choice Awards Favorite Country Song: "Before He Cheats"
Favorite Female Singer
Grammy Awards Best New Artist
Best Female Country Vocal Performance: "Jesus, Take The Wheel"
CMT Music Awards Video of the Year: "Before He Cheats"
Female Video of the Year: "Before He Cheats"
Academy of Country Music Awards Female Vocalist of the Year
Album of The Year: "Some Hearts"
Video of The Year: "Before He Cheats"
Country Music Association Awards Female Vocalist of the Year
Single Of The Year: "Before He Cheats"
American Music Awards Favorite Country Female Artist
Favorite Country Album: "Some Hearts"
T-Mobile Text-In Award (Artist of the Year)
Billboard Music Awards Female Country Artist of the Year
Country Album for "Some Hearts"
Country Artist of the Year
Female Billboard 200 Artist of the Year
Country Albums Artist of the Year
Worf Music Awards Best Country Female Video for "Before He Cheats"
Best Contemporary Album for "Carnival Ride"
Grammy Awards Best Female Country Vocal Performance: "Before He Cheats"
Academy of Country Music Awards Female Vocalist of the Year
European Country Music Association Awards Female Vocalist of the Year
Teen Choice Awards Red Carpet Fashion Icon
Country Music Association Awards Female Vocalist of the Year
American Music Awards Favorite Country Album: "Carnival Ride"
Billboard Music Awards Country Songs Artist of the Year
CMT Online Awards Most Digitally Active Female Artist
Most Streamed Country Song of the Year: "All-American Girl"
35th People's Choice Awards Favorite Country Song: "Last Name"
Favorite Female Artist
Favorite Star 35 and Under
Country Universe Reader’s Choice Awards Artist of the Year
Female Vocalist of the Year
Single of the Year- "Just a Dream"
Music Video of the Year- "Just a Dream"
Member of the Grand Ole Opry
I probably have missed a few of Carrie's Honors!
This one review is completely pointless when I look at all that Our Carrie has accomplished! Thankfully, many, many, many other "critics", voters, and actual important individuals in the music industry see things completely differently than 9513!
Quote:
Originally Posted by lab
Oh, come on!!! ... TRADITIONAL COUNTRY CRITICS!!! ... Carrie Underwood should continually adapt her songs to changing needs and opportunities. Although this is a traditional country song, Carrie's version is "CONTEMPORARY COUNTRY" - "MARKET-ORIENTED INNOVATION WITH QUALITY ARTISTRY". Carrie's version is very dramatic in its musical cues, great pacing and with infectious vocal masterpiece!!! In today's music climate, Carrie Underwood should not follow your advice because she will end up NOT selling albums anymore like what happened to other traditional country singers or what you call in your own mind as "TRUE TRADITIONAL COUNTRY MUSIC SINGER WHO CAN NOT SELL ALBUMS ANYMORE". A STRONGER MARKET-ORIENTED STRATEGIES IS NECESSSARY ... THAT IS "CONTEMPORARY COUNTRY MUSIC". THIS KIND OF REVIEW IS GETTING OLD ALREADY. THE REASON WHY CARRIE UNDERWOOD HAS A "PHENOMENAL SUCCESS" IN HER CAREER IS BECAUSE SHE IS "CONTEMPORARY COUNTRY ARTIST"!!! PERIOD!!!
VERY WELL SAID, CASSIE2!!!
Carrie won 47 Awards out of 71 Nominations in just three years of the release of her debut album. Carrie was trusted by the Grammys to perform for three consecutive years at Grammy Awards Shows. Carrie was the only country artist who performed at Movies Rock. Carrie was with Martina McBride at Fashion Rock. Carrie was side by side with the superstars of other music format at Stand Up To Cancer at the Fashion Rock, the following year. Carrie was trusted by the prestigious "The Walt Disney Company" to sing for their history making movie "Enchanted". Carrie performed every year in all Prestigious Award Shows and at American Idol Show. Carrie already sold 9.3 Million + Units for just two albums! Carrie already had 8 Consecutive # 1 Hit Singles. Carrie performed in sold out crowd in almost all of the 137 cities and sold 1.2 Million TICKETS just for the Year 2008!!!
I just signed on now, and look at the nasty comments that Jim Malec had to say about Carrie. He is a known Carrie critic on the 9513, but tonight he was particularly harsh. I am not sure what started all the trouble, but he is a self-righteous little jerk who seems to thrive on his own perceived self-importance. This blog comment says it all. It is unreal!
DIRECT QUOTE from a 9513 Blogger:
Jim Malec
January 30, 2009 at 4:42 pm Permalink Oh. My. God. Are we really going to start dissing Taylor Swift here? Again? Is there room for only one young female pop country songstress?
OK, let’s open that can of worms.
Taylor Swift may be a crappy singer, but at least I feel like she has something to say. She has a story she’s trying to tell. Underwood? Not so much. And, in Swift’s case, that counts for something.
Underwood’s supposed greatness is predicated on her voice, but if she’s going to build a career on a foundation of singing, she deserves to be held to a very high standard when it comes to…well…singing.
And frankly, it all feels underwhelming to me. When she sings, I feel like I’m listening to a really, really good karaoke singer. All the notes are there, but there’s this detachment, almost as if she doesn’t own her own material when she sings it. Underwood has a fantastic voice, but she is nowhere near a top-tier singer, because she doesn’t seem to understand that singing is about more than hitting notes.
yea this is what really makes me mad
i know everyone has their opinion and noones opinion is wrong, but i think that when your only 1 out of many that dont agree...then you are a little off
i really dont understand how he can say carrie only hits the notes
she has soo much emotion in her songs....JAD at the CMAS?....and in concert.........crying in DFTRM? im sorry i just dont agree at all
i dont even see how someone can be mean and harsh to someone who wouldnt hurt a fly lol
and these critics must love drama becasue most are comparing ts o carrie and that is not goin to get them ne where
3x cma...2x ACM,,soon to be 3 female vocalist of the year
yes vocals are on hitting notes...but to win FVOTY you need more than that and carrie has it
Sorry but I feel more in Carrie's music than in alot of other artist's music. Otherwise I wouldn't be a fan of Carrie and follow her career like I do. So this reviewer doesn't speak for me and countless millions that went out and bought her music too and loved it....lol. Can't wait for the next album I'm sure that review on 9513 will just be lovely too. Can't wait. (sarcasm).
) . I'm so sick of 9513 and their biases. They don't feel anything from Carrie's music b/c they choose to not feel anything from the get go. Carrie we love you and your music and you are doing a great job and you and your music does touch people. If people like this don't like it, tough. I bought your album SH b/c of your song JTTW which moved me so much I cried as i heard it on the radio not even knowing it was you singing this song until the dj mentioned your name after the song was over. I said "wow, Carrie Underwood?....really? that girl from AI?, really? she sounds like a pro. and this song is so touching/moving." That song had an effect on me so much that I then checked you out on youtube and loved your live performances and so bought your album and starting following you ever since and loved her music. You bring alot of joy, happiness, and brightness into this world. Keep it up 
Linear Mode
