All-American Girl
Twisted
The final round!!! Twisted has been patiently waiting to make its debut in this game, and now it faces off against All-American Girl. Who will win?!?!
Voting will be open for 3 days.
"Twisted," easily. It's still one of my favorites from Carnival Ride.
All American Girl.Never likes Twisted.My least favorite song from Carnival Ride.
I adore Twisted, and I actually think it's the better song, but point blank, I can't vote against AAG. My favorite CR song.
K, now I'm just voting against AAG out of spite that it beat YWFT. Y'all are crazy.
My vote goes to "All-American Girl" based on the sequence: "Get Out of This Town" > "All-American Girl" > ...> "Twisted" > ... (in both terms of favorite status and listened to times)
------
I think this is one of the last rounds
All-American Girl for me. I love Twisted but the former just tells a great story with a fun melody and it's so well-written too. Twisted would still be in my top 5 from Carnival Ride though.
I voted AAG. I've always found Twisted good, but not a standout track.
I still think the finale should've had either Just a Dream, I Know You Won't, or So Small in it though![]()
All-American Girl for the prize!
A-AG. It's the song that brought me on the "Carnival Ride" on country radio. Twisted is nice, but I clearly remember it being the only song I didn't listen to/get acquainted with when preparing to see my first Carrie concert.