I loved when Harry mentored in season nine because he knew exactly what he was talking about and did a wonderful job relating to the contestants. He was also hilarious.
Pink knows her stuff, and would give her honest opinion. I think she could give honest critiques without being rude.
I'm on the fence about Shania. She has the experience, but I don't know that she could really let someone know their performance wasn't good. I think she might have a tendency to sugarcoat things.
All of these rumors are driving me crazy lol. With each new name that gets tossed into the mix, I question what kind of chemistry the new panel will have.
listen I LOVE carrie but lets get real, it would be too boring, shes too nice. It just be like when AI got ellen, everyone loves them but they are just to soft-no backbone.
on the other hand Kelly I have no idea why she hates idol so much and talks bad bout it always, she would be perfect, and yeah miley does sound cool and she DOES have experience I mean the gril has been touring since she was 14 years old and has done it all, talented or mediocre, she would be a great judge for the younger contestants, now for the older why not faith hil or Alicia Keys?
I don't know how they are supposed to revive idol when all the judges they pick always leave after so many seasons. It's getting really pathetic now.
Kelly has no business ties to Idol anymore, so she has decided to take her mentoring skills to The Voice and Duets. She has said that she wouldn't want to sit on the Idol judging panel because it would be too hard for her, seeing as she knows exactly what those contestants are up against. She does enjoy meeting them, though, and sharing her own experiences in the business.
OMG i didnt see it that way :s thanks for clearing it up for me. idk I just think that idol should be smart and hire someone not too powerful(like a producer or nicole scherzinger,its an exampe) and give them the first season a 1 year contract and then make them a 3-4 more seasons agreement that way they dont look pathetic and used every two years, it now looking ike disney channel where all these teenage girls use it and when they make it big BYEBYE
I totally agree with you about being a creature of habit lol. I could say I wouldn't watch if this person or that person were on the judging panel, but I know I'll watch regardless . I've dedicated a decade to this show, so what's a few more years?
Two down, one more to go.
Kanye would be more honest that anyone ever on that show.
I dont like Ryan so for me, they can get rid of him too. But for some reason people love him, so I dont see that happening. And I dont like Randy, so I dont care what happens with him.
Personally I'm glad Jennifer is leaving - she only seemed to be there to push her own singles or do her dancing, etc. Not a fan - love her movies but Idol took away any interest I had in her. Just too self centered for me. Mr Tyler only seemed to be filling a chair w/o acting like he knew why. Loved his duets with Carrie. Hopefully they'll come up with some better choices than those mentioned so far. I couldn't handle Cowell but the drama seemed to keep the show alive or something as its had issues since he left.
LOL if Kanye and Pink are judges, I will never want to fastforward past the judges' comments again!
Jennifer named some people who she believed would be on par to replace her -- Bon Jovi, Bono, and Mick Jagger.
This lady has a one way ticket on the crazy train if she thinks she's as big as Mick Jagger or Bono.
yes its so true about randy he by mistake comfirmed it in a tweet let me no what you think that randy is leaving